Menu

college football championship saturday

Raining On Its Own Parade: College Football Debases Championship Saturday

,

The concept of a conference championship game in college football was first introduced by the SEC in 1992. As the years went by and more teams started to play a title game, it seemed like an idea that had tremendous promise. The first Saturday of December was going to be known as “College Conference Championship Saturday”, the perfect prelude to New Year’s Day in the cycle of the sport. Right at the moment when Championship Saturday should be in its glory, it’s instead imploding—and at college football’s own hand.

I could go off about the winner of the Big Ten Championship Game being left aside for the second straight year in favor of a team that hadn’t won its own division, but I’m going to save that for further down. I want to start by focusing on something far more damaging to the integrity of championship games and that’s what happened with Central Florida and outgoing head coach Scott Frost.

GREAT 1980s SPORTS MOMENTS
Buy the book for yourself or as a Christmas gift today. 

Central Florida was playing Memphis for the title in the American Athletic Conference. UCF was undefeated, and it was essentially understood that the winner of this game would get the major bowl bid that’s reserved for the smaller conferences—or that the winner would represent the Little Five in the New Year’s Six, if I can throw a lot of numbers at you. This game was everything Championship Saturday was supposed to be about.

And it was an extraordinary football game, especially if you like offense. Central Florida survived a strong upset bid, won 62-55 and was rewarded with a Peach Bowl invite to play Auburn and show what they can do against the big boys.

So what’s the problem? The problem is that UCF’s head coach, Scott Frost, accepted the head coaching job at Nebraska, during the game.

Football coaches, more than any professional class I know, solemnly pontificate about “focus”, “eliminating distractions” and “putting the team first.” All of these are fine attributes. They all went out the window when a head coach playing for a championship couldn’t be bothered to keep the focus on the game at hand.

This incident has been glossed over by media members. When it was reported during the MAC Championship Game that was running concurrently with UCF-Memphis, analyst Rod Gilmore said simply that everyone knew Frost was going to Nebraska (where he was quarterback on the school’s last national championship team in 1997). And further, Gilmore said, all Frost had to do was send a text message to his agent just saying “Yes” and confirming the offer.

I’m wondering how a coach would react if one his players finalized some plans of their own during the game. It doesn’t have to be a multi-million dollar contract offer. It could be something as basic as the girlfriend making plans for the evening with friends and wanting him to confirm it. Hey, all he has to do is text “Yes”. Let’s see how far any player gets with that.

Contrary to what you may think from this, I don’t dislike Scott Frost. I actually sympathize with him. He, like coaches around the country, are put in these ridiculous positions because of a recruiting calendar that devalues the very championship games and bowl games that kids spend all year fighting to reach.

High school recruits can begin signing with their schools on December 20, right as bowl games are beginning. Schools making a coaching change are in a complete panic—understandably so, to make sure their head coach is in place, along with as much of the staff as possible. Hence, the coaching carousel begins right after Thanksgiving dinner.

Scott Frost is certainly not the first to be put in this position. Every year we see coaches who’ve had successful years be forced to abandon their teams at bowl time. Or coaches that are getting fired aren’t even allowed to coach the bowl game, such is the imperative to get the new regime in place in time for recruiting. So much for the virtue of “finish the season” that parents tell kids when they go out for sports in school.

The situation is so ludicrous that UCF athletic director Danny White actually had to say that he expected Frost to coach his team in the Peach Bowl rather than immediately leaving. To his credit, Frost will and Nebraska is okay with it. But it’s not the norm—in 2009, after coaching Cincinnati to an undefeated season and Sugar Bowl bid, then-head coach Brian Kelly left the Bearcats behind to get a head start on coaching Notre Dame.

It’s long past time to make the structural changes necessary to protect the integrity of conference championship games and the ensuing bowl games. Do what the NFL does and ban any coaching hires until a team has completed its season. Make it easier on the schools by eliminating the early signing period for recruits. There’s a National Signing Day in early February that ends the recruiting year. Make that the day kids can sign. That leaves enough time for bowl season to end and coaches in Frost’s situation will still have enough time to recruit for their new employer.

I’ve singled out Frost here only because the text message during the game was my breaking point on a problem that annoys me every December. I want to point out that Frost himself expressed sentiments agreeing with me, in the aftermath of his team’s victory over Memphis. Here’s how The Orlando Sentinel reported the coach’s comments in the press conference.

He wanted his players to enjoy their moment in the championship spotlight and waited until 30 minutes after his postgame press conference to tell the Knights he accepted the Nebraska job.

He fought back tears during the postgame press conference as they described what he meant to them.“They should give you time off after the season to make a decision, but they don’t (emphasis added)” Frost said when asked about the reports he had accepted the job.

Frost later added, “I’m going to talk to the team first. They’re hard decisions and they don’t give you enough time to make them.” (emphasis added)

COLLEGE FOOTBALL PLAYOFF CONTROVERSY

The cause of making Championship Saturday a showcase day for college football took another hit when the College Football Playoff Selection Committee opted for Alabama over Ohio State for the final Playoff spot. The Tide were 11-1 and finished second to Auburn in the West. Ohio State finished 11-2 and won the Big Ten.

Look, I believe the Playoff should be restricted to conference champions. If you disagree, I understand. Is it politically incorrect to say that “some of my best friends believe in using W-L record”? That’s a separate debate.

I do hope though, the advocates for Alabama over Ohio State this year, and Ohio State over Penn State last year in the same circumstance, realize what they’re doing—they’re essentially saying that the safest place to be on Championship Saturday is 11-1 and sitting at home.

Coming into Saturday, Alabama was ranked behind two teams that had to play, Wisconsin and Auburn. The Badgers and Tigers both lost. Under the logic applied by the Selection Committee, both would have been better off not playing. If the criteria is going to boil down to “fewest losses”, then there’s an obvious advantage to not playing a game at all.

There you have it. Instead of being a showcase day for the best of college football, Championship Saturday is a day when coaches have to accept new jobs in the middle of games and Playoff hopefuls are safer being at home. Next year, when I make my TV viewing decisions on the first Saturday of December, I’ll remember that.

College Football Championship Saturday: Six Crowns On The Line

, , , , , ,

It’s time for the best day of the year on the college football calendar, and one of the best days to be a sports fan. College Football Championship Saturday, the first Saturday of December has taken the place of New Year’s Day in the culture of college football.

While January 1 still has its run of bowl games, there are no longer championships settled. What we have in store for Saturday is different–six conference championship games will be played, another will be settled and by Sunday we’ll know who’s playing for the national title and who’s going to BCS bowls.


The only conferences that don’t have championship games are the Big 12, American Athletic and the Sun Belt. The Big 12 has the next best thing—back-to-back games between good teams that will settle its bid. TheSportsNotebook previewed the Oklahoma-Oklahoma State (Noon ET, ABC) and Texas-Baylor (3:30 PM ET, Fox) as part of our Big 12 bowl projections earlier this week.

Central Florida secured the American Athletic bid when Cincinnati lost to Louisville last night. In the Sun Belt, UL-Lafayette will go for an outright title on Saturday night in South Alabama. If ULL loses, they share the crown with Arkansas State.

With that out of the way, let’s get on to business and look at some championship football games. You can watch for thirteen hours straight, and this is how the day breaks down, in sequential order…

Conference USA: Marshall at Rice (Noon ET, ESPN2): Marshall is coming off an impressive 59-28 waxing of East Carolina to claim a division title, and that explains why the Thundering Herd are a 6.5 point favorite on the road. Rice has very quietly matched Marshall’s 7-1 league record, and the Owls’ only losses outside the league were a close defeat to Houston and a 52-31 defeat at Texas A&M that was competitive into the second half.

Marshall quarterback Rakeem Cato is one of the most dynamic in the country, while Rice counters with a pretty good signal-caller in Taylor McHargue, and a solid conventional runner in Charles Ross. At the start of the season I picked the Owls to win the C-USA title. Even though they might be the underdog on Saturday, I’ve got them at home and getting points. No reason to change course now.


Missouri-Auburn (4 PM ET, CBS): The biggest game of Championship Saturday goes from the Georgia Dome in Atlanta. We know about Auburn’s magic ride–the turnaround from the 2-10 season, the upset of Texas A&M, the miracle pass to beat Georgia and finally the stunning 108-yard return of a missed field goal by Chris Davis to beat Alabama last week.

We also know about how well-coached Auburn is with Gus Malzahn, how tough a running back Tre Mason is, and how there’s a very good chance that a win here would create enough voter momentum to vault them past Ohio State and into #2, regardless of what the Buckeyes do later on Saturday night.

But do we know enough about Missouri? This is a team whose only loss came in double overtime to South Carolina when the backup quarterback was in the game. Missouri also won at Georgia–decisively no less–without starting QB James Franklin. With Franklin in the lineup, the Tigers won some tough money games the last two weeks against Ole Miss and Texas A&M to hold on to the SEC East.

Missouri likely can’t pass Ohio State in the polls without a Buckeye defeat, but Gary Pinkel’s team deserves the same consideration as Auburn. They’ve got a solid runner of their own in Henry Josey. That’s why I’m picking Mizzou to win this game–the letdown factor for Auburn is part of it, but another part is that I think Missouri is simply underappreciated.

Stanford at Arizona State (7:45 PM ET, ESPN): These teams met earlier in the year in Palo Alto and Stanford put the smackdown on ASU, a 42-28 win that wasn’t nearly that close. Arizona State hasn’t lost a conference game since, although they did drop a neutral site game in Dallas to Notre Dame. Stanford slipped up against Utah and USC–both teams that the Sun Devils beat–and that allowed Arizona State to claim homefield advantage for this game.

Arizona State will be without its best running back, Marion Grice, who is expected to miss the game with a leg injury. That’s going to put a lot more pressure on Taylor Kelly, the quarterback who will have to now carry a bigger load in the running game, as well as throwing the ball.

Stanford has no such balance problems. Tyler Gaffney is one of the best runners in the nation, a 1,400-yard back. Kevin Hogan’s been inconsistent at quarterback and the biggest fear for the Cardinal is that he makes some mistakes, especially if Arizona State gets gut pressure with nose tackle Will Sutton.

If Hogan can avoid the kind of mistakes that cost his team the USC game, Stanford is going to win. I think they’re the better team and only the fact the game is in Tempe gives me any pause at all. Oddsmakers see the teams as even, and give ASU the (-3) edge for homefield, but I’m going with the home dog.


Duke-Florida State (8 PM ET, ABC): This been a great ride for Duke, with narrow wins over Virginia Tech, Wake Forest and North Carolina keying their ride to the ACC Championship Game in Charlotte. But it’s been a dominant ride for Florida State, whose undefeated season and #1 ranking was highlighted by a 51-14 thrashing of Clemson on the road, a team who will likely end up in a major bowl game.

Florida State’s top two rushers have more yardage than Duke’s best runner. While Blue Devil coach David Cutliffe has a deserved reputation for his offensive innovation, quarterback Anthony Boone has been a little mistake-prone this year, and now faces the fastest defense he’s seen all season. Now that Jameis Winston has been cleared of sexual assault charges, there’s going to be a big burden lifted from the Seminole program.

The ‘Noles are a (-29.5) favorite and the only way they don’t cover that number is if they don’t want to.

Ohio State-Michigan State (8:15 PM ET, Fox): By the time the Buckeyes take the field in Indianapolis they’ll know if they need to win with style (if Auburn wins the SEC) or if just winning will suffice (if Missouri wins). What Urban Meyer’s team can’t do is allow themselves to think about this, because Ohio State is about to face the toughest defense they, or most anyone else, has seen all year.

Michigan State has allowed fewer than 10 points in five of the last six games, and have five players that made first-team All-Conference. The matchup of Sparty’s defense against the tremendous speed the Buckeyes have on offense–from quarterback Braxton Miller to Devin Smith at receiver, is going to be a great battle for control of the edge. How successful Ohio State can be running Carlos Hyde between the tackles will likely decide if they can eventually break something on the perimeter.

Then there’s the Ohio State defense against the Michigan State offense, which is less than a titanic showdown. Ohio State just gave up 41 points to a Michigan offense that was previously noted for its incompetence, the low point for a unit whose mediocrity has been apparent all year.

Michigan State’s offense won’t exactly remind anyone of the Denver Broncos though. Sparty only put up 14 points against Purdue, and anything their offense does accomplish is often a fruit of the field position the defense sets them up with.

Ohio State is a (-5.5) favorite and I’m picking the Buckeyes. I like and respect Michigan State head coach Mark Dantonio. When it comes to Meyer, let’s just say that I’m less than admiring. But Meyer in a big game is not to be trifled with and if Ohio State’s offense can just find a few big plays with their speed, they’ll win.

Utah State at Fresno State (10 PM ET, CBS): How’s this for a contrast in styles–Fresno State lost its shot at a BCS bowl game because they gave up 62 points to San Jose State last week, while still scoring 52 themselves. Meanwhile, Utah State has given up 51 points in the last five games combined.

That five-game stretch covers the point in the season when Utah State’s all-everything quarterback Chuckie Keeton was lost for the year. While the schedule cooperated, the Aggies beat two bowl-eligible teams in UNLV and Colorado State, and Wyoming would have been bowl-eligible if not for Utah State knocking them off.

Fresno State is just a (-3.5) favorite, showing how much respect the Bulldogs lost last week–the number indicates Las Vegas sees them as barely better than Utah State on a neutral field, even without Keeton. I admire what Utah State has done all year, but in the first game without Keeton that lost decisively to Boise State and this game is a little higher in caliber. I’ll take Fresno.